Hello class,
Visual evidence. It’s the key to conveying the documentarians’ themes and ideas to the audience. The essays emphasized the importance of visual evidence. How can someone tell a story without any sound, just visuals? Silent films are prime examples, as the essays point out. Their only option WAS visual evidence. They shot scenes with intention. A documentary highly focuses on the visual with the inclusion of sound to reflect one another. While being in the modern world, how can we tell the story of local nurses during COVID without going inside the hospital? I’d want to tell the story of the physical, emotional, and mental impact the pandemic has over the nurses on the front lines.
“A critical part of the preparation for any documentary project should be to ask yourself what you can show your audience that will help them to understand the subject” (pg. 99).
To tell my story, I’d want to show an interview with a nurse from a local hospital. The audience gets to see behavioral evidence from this interview, the responses to questions about their work, family, and personal life resulting from COVID. However, the essay points out that interviews usually aren’t evidence. How can someone believe what a person is saying if all they see/hear is that person? What does that struggle look like? The essays highlighted the importance of location when conducting an interview.
“If you’re filming an expert on juvenile delinquency who is proposing alternatives to putting adolescents in adult prisons, film her at the prison rather than her office” (pg. 98).
The hospital is off the table. But COVID isn’t solely located at the hospital. The world “pandemic” means affecting the entire nation. Filming this interview in locations that would usually be full of people, perhaps a mall or a school, showing a scene of the interviewee taking off or leaving on their medical mask. These locations point out the impact of COVID on our environment that would allow for the interview to touch on, reflecting points from the dialogue with visual evidence. I would also ask the interviewee if they could supply and photographs of themselves on the job, of their family, or simply include publicly available images of nurses, patients, and other medical staff dealing with COVID.
“You have to plan for filming in situations and at locations likely to provide useful visual evidence, and you must also be prepared to recognize visual evidence when it occurs, even when it doesn’t show up in the way you might have expected” (pg. 99).
A distinction is made about B-roll and visual evidence in the essays. “B-roll mentality” is a worry of the writer that filmmakers fall into. They disregard looking for the scenes that tell the story and instead look for scenes relating to the story.
“Any time a shot in a documentary could be taken out of the film and replaced with something completely different, it’s B-roll. If it has to be there, it’s visual evidence” (pg.107).
A scene where the interviewee is washing their scrubs early in the morning before work tells us just how often this person is working during the pandemic. Another scene of them arriving home late at night after a busy shift. A car ride with the nurse showing their route to work at the start of their shift. These scenes could be replaced with shots inside the hospital if allowed, but the replacement isn’t necessary. These shots tell the story, the struggles of nurses in all aspects of life from the COVID pandemic while at home.
I’ve garnered a new appreciation for the documentarian and the work that goes behind creating a truly authentic story.
Thanks for reading,
Caleb
View Post